Which is a better buy: cheap or expensive batteries?
What do watermelons in a slingshot and battery selection have in common? Rhett Allain. He’s a physics professor who blogs about science, technology and geeky things.
Watermelons in a slingshot:
A few years ago, a competitive reality show, The Amazing Race, had a "watermelons in a slingshot" competition. Think Angry Birds...but different. Based on the show’s video, Rhett calculated both the speed and impact, OUCH!, of the watermelon.
Battery selection:
Ever wonder which is a better buy, cheap or expensive batteries? Earlier this week, Rhett deciphered the answer to this question by breaking this down into two separate questions:
- “How much energy is stored in the battery?” and
- “What does the battery cost?”
The professor made measurements and ran calculations on Energizer, Duracell and Dollar Store batteries.
Results: The more expensive batteries stored more energy. But, what happens if you divide the energy by battery cost? He terms this the “money-energy density”. Which battery has the best money-energy density? Basically, all three batteries have a similar money-energy density. Is that what you would have guessed?
Rhett notes however that how the battery is used may be a determinant as to which type to select. For example, some electronics do not function below a certain power threshold: think Wii or battery-powered objects that move. The cheaper battery looses power fairly rapidly so this may be an issue with power-sensitive electronics.
